TRANSIT asks for permission for the placement of cookies

Establishment of Transition Bro Gwaun

Date interview: March 16 2016
Name interviewer: Noel Longhurst
Name interviewee: Tom Latter
Position interviewee: Founder of Transition Bro Gwaun and member of core group.


Values New Organizing New Doing Motivation Local/regional government Interpersonal relations Formalizing Emergence Civil Society organizations Challenging institutions

This is a CTP of initiative: Transition Bro Gwaun (UK)

This CTP involves the formation of Transition Bro Gwaun as an official transition initiative. It is based in  in the town of Fishguard on the south west coast of Wales. 

Co-production

Tom Latter is an organic farmer who first became aware of the Transition movement through the Soil Association which is a UK based organic agriculture advocacy and accreditation organization. [Rob Hopkins was a trustee of the Soil Association for three years in the second half of the 2000]. Patrick Holden, the then Director of the Soil Association, was a keen supporter of the Transition movement in its early years. The interviewee thinks that he heard about a Transition related meeting in Lampeter through the Soil Association. This was held on Tuesday April 3rd 2007 at the Arts Hall, University of Wales. Rob Hopkins – the co-founder of the Transition movement – spoke at the meeting. 
 
Tom felt that the Transition town idea would be of interest to other people in the area because at that time there wasn't a focus for environmental concern so there was no issue with "treading on anybody's toes".
 
Following the Lampeter meeting, Tom brought people who he thought would be interested in the approach together. A couple of other friends had been at the meeting too.They got around a dozen people together and held some public meetings which were quite well attended (by around 25–30 people). The people were likeminded people (interested in green issues) who were partly from the farming community. A few came from a local wholefoods buying co-operative as there was no wholefoods shop in Fishguard
 
They invited Rob Hopkins along to speak at a larger meeting (an "unleashing"). That raised awareness of the group in the community and thereafter they constituted themselves into a formal unincorporated community group [later, in 2011, they would register as a company, and in 2014 as a charity]. Anne Bushall, Brian and Dot Jackson and Chris Samba formed the core group, along with him.
 
For the early meetings, they picked topics that they thought people would be interested in - for example recycling. They screened films in the local cinema. For example, they had a memorable screening of the "Message in the Waves" documentary by Rebecca Hoskings. They tried out various things from the Transition Network 12 steps - including holding an "open space". These were set out in the Transition Primer which provided guidance on how to set up groups.
 
These activities were reasonably successful. Nonetheless, the interviewee doesn't think that they would get as many people if they tried to launch it now. It was a relatively new idea and it was a new environmental group.
 
His own interests in the Transition idea were based on interest in energy and Energy Return on Investment and how this linked to our survival and sustainability. It is what also motivated his interest in organic farming. Frustrated by the fact that the government weren't addressing the problem, he subsequently felt that if communities showed what could be done, it would give government the strength to take ome action but we are still in that "limbo state".
 
Two agencies in the county were helpful:
  • Pembrokshire Association of Voluntary Services. For a nominal fee, they provided access to resources and support for voluntary groups.
  • PLANED – Pembrokeshire Local Action Network for Enterprise and Development. They are based in Narbeth and have been running under diferent names. Also been very supportive. Focused on sustainability.

Local authorities (municipalities) more helpful currently, although they did help with allotments early on.

Related events

Tom knew Chris Samba (a key co-founder) through some local anti-GM crop protests in 2001. There was a proposal to locate part of the government's GM crop trials near Mathry. So there was local objection and opposition, particularly amongst organic farmers but also from the local community in general. The trial was abandoned before it was planted. Some of the later Transition activists met through this campaign. Even the local paper was campaigning against it.
 
Rob Hopkins meeting: 200 people came, hired the big hall at the local secondary school. He sometimes wonders why some of those who came didn't then engage with the Transition initiative. About half the audience were not from the immediate locality and came from across wider Pembrokeshire. As a result at least three other local Transition groups started up: Haverford West, Narbeth and Tylee valley.
 
All the subsequent Transition Bro Gwaun activity followed this CTP. For example, in the earlier years they did three or four carnival floats in succession. These were quite successful, they were eye-catching and a lot of people got involved. At the beginning they didn't really form sub-groups, these came later e.g. Energy group (2010) and Transition café group (2012).
 
Most recently, they organized a two day local regeneration meeting (Cymuned Unol – Community Together) held on the 14th and the 15th March 2016 which had Jay Tompt and Julian Dobson (both from Totnes) to speak. This brought in a wide range of local actors - certainly more than would have happened a few more years ago. They hosted the event but didn't claim ownership of it

 

Contestation

A couple of people dropped out after it had been set up, because they felt they weren't needed after it had been established. For them, setting it up was far more important than what happened afterwards.
 
Remarkably, little turnover otherwise and no major fallings out. The key organisers of Transition Bro Gwaun are reasonably thick skinned and share a commitment to stick in there and not let go. There is a sense of personal responsibility which means that activists don't want to let the side down, in fear of standstills and inaction. 

Anticipation

The launch felt significant in that it raised awareness of the initiative and gave them some momentum. Some kind of renewable energy was always on the agenda but the Transition café project came out of the blue.

Learning

Tom's main ambition for the Transition group was to raise awareness of environmental issues because it wasn't that clear what could be done practically, apart from the idea of developing new local allotments.
 
The development of specific projects has depended a lot on chance. One of the main volunteers in the wind project is a wind developer (he has acted as an agent to help farmers put turbines up which was very helpful experience). If he hadn't been around, it would have been a lot more difficult.
 
A specific learning point: Making contacts is important - and not just with the obvious candidates. When you start something often the usual suspects will turn up but to make progress you need to get outside that immediate group. It helps to have wider connections.
 
The majority of the group have been people who are not very native to the area (i.e. incomers). It is about half and half. Often the civil society groups seem to be set up by the non-natives, often this is what happens because people who have lived here a long time accept things how they are. He is local but has also spent time away.

Stay informed. Subscribe for project updates by e-mail.

loader